Key Differences Between Liberal and Marxist Perspectives on the State
The liberal and Marxist perspectives on the state offer contrasting views rooted in their broader ideological foundations. While liberalism emphasizes individual rights, limited government, and the rule of law, Marxism views the state as an instrument of class domination and a tool for enforcing capitalist interests.
1. Nature and Role of the State
- Liberal Perspective: Liberals see the state as a neutral arbiter that exists to protect individual rights, freedom, and property. It is established through a social contract to ensure order, justice, and the protection of citizens' interests. The state operates within a legal framework and derives legitimacy from the consent of the governed.
- Marxist Perspective: Marxists view the state as a class instrument—a structure designed to maintain the dominance of the ruling (bourgeois) class over the working class (proletariat). For Marx, the state is not neutral but is inherently biased in favor of the capitalist system, reinforcing exploitation and inequality.
2. Origin of the State
- Liberal Perspective: The liberal theory, drawing from thinkers like Locke and Rousseau, holds that the state arises from a voluntary agreement among individuals to form a government that protects their natural rights.
- Marxist Perspective: Marxists argue that the state emerged historically as a mechanism of class control, arising when private property led to class divisions. The state develops to manage class conflict and protect the interests of the economically dominant class.
3. Function of the State
- Liberal Perspective: The liberal state is expected to ensure law and order, uphold individual liberties, and facilitate free-market competition. Its role is largely administrative and regulatory, intervening only when necessary to correct market failures.
- Marxist Perspective: The Marxist state functions to protect capitalist interests, maintain class structure, and suppress revolutionary activity. Marxists advocate for the eventual "withering away" of the state after the proletarian revolution, leading to a classless, stateless society (communism).
4. View on Democracy
- Liberal Perspective: Liberals champion representative democracy, where the state reflects the will of the people through elected institutions.
- Marxist Perspective: Marxists criticize liberal democracy as bourgeois democracy, arguing that it disguises class rule under the illusion of political equality, while real power remains with capitalist elites.
Conclusion:
In summary, while liberals see the state as a protector of individual freedoms and a neutral guardian of law, Marxists perceive it as a tool of class oppression. These differing views reflect broader ideological commitments to capitalism (liberalism) versus socialism and class struggle (Marxism).
Subscribe on YouTube - NotesWorld
For PDF copy of Solved Assignment
Any University Assignment Solution
.webp)
