Compare the Liberal and Marxist approaches to political science. What are the key differences in their views on state and society?

Comparison of Liberal and Marxist Approaches to Political Science

Liberal Approach: Liberalism, as an approach to political science, emphasizes individual liberty, democracy, and the protection of human rights. It advocates for limited government intervention and promotes the idea of a free market economy, where individuals have the freedom to pursue their interests. Liberals believe in the rule of law, constitutionalism, and political pluralism, arguing that a democratic state should be structured to ensure the protection of individual freedoms and rights.

Key Features:

1. State and Society: Liberals view the state as a neutral entity that exists to protect the rights and freedoms of individuals. The state is expected to provide security, uphold the rule of law, and ensure justice, but it should not interfere excessively in the private lives of individuals.
2. Role of the Market: Liberalism supports a capitalist economy, where market forces drive economic growth. It sees capitalism as a system that benefits individual freedom and fosters innovation, provided that the state ensures fairness and prevents abuses.
3. Human Nature: Liberals believe in the inherent rationality and goodness of individuals, emphasizing that people should be free to make their own decisions.

Marxist Approach: Marxism, developed by Karl Marx, views political science through the lens of class struggle and economic determinism. Marxists argue that society is divided into classes based on their relationship to the means of production, primarily the bourgeoisie (capitalist class) and the proletariat (working class). According to Marxism, the state is an instrument of the ruling class, designed to maintain the interests of the bourgeoisie.

Key Features:

1. State and Society: Marxists see the state as an instrument of class oppression. The state is not neutral but is shaped by the interests of the ruling class (capitalists). In capitalist societies, the state perpetuates the dominance of capitalists over workers, suppressing the proletariat’s interests.
2. Role of the Market: Marxism critiques capitalism as inherently exploitative. Marxists believe that capitalism leads to inequality and alienation, and it ultimately needs to be replaced by socialism, where the means of production are collectively owned and controlled.
3. Human Nature: Marxists emphasize the influence of material conditions on human behavior, arguing that individuals' actions and consciousness are shaped by their socio-economic conditions, particularly their class position.

Key Differences:

1. View of the State: Liberals see the state as a neutral entity protecting individual freedoms, whereas Marxists view the state as an instrument of class oppression used by the bourgeoisie to maintain control.
2. Role of the Economy: Liberals support capitalism and private property, believing it fosters individual freedom. Marxists, however, see capitalism as a source of inequality and exploitation and advocate for its abolition in favor of socialism.
3. Human Nature: Liberals focus on individual autonomy and rationality, while Marxists emphasize that individuals are shaped by economic structures and class relations.

Conclusion:

While the liberal approach prioritizes individual freedoms and democratic governance within a capitalist framework, the Marxist approach critiques capitalism and advocates for a revolutionary change to establish a classless society. The key distinction lies in their views on the state, the economy, and the role of class in shaping societal structures.

Subscribe on YouTube - NotesWorld

For PDF copy of Solved Assignment

Any University Assignment Solution

WhatsApp - 9113311883 (Paid)