In Leo Tolstoy's short story "Three Hermits," the theme of individual belief triumphing over religious dogma is central to the narrative. This story is a powerful exploration of spirituality, simplicity, and the idea that true faith is often found in the hearts of individuals rather than within the confines of religious institutions. Here, we will delve deeply into the text and discuss how "Three Hermits" presents the notion that individual belief can indeed triumph over religious dogma.
Summary of "Three Hermits":
Before delving into the theme of individual belief, let's briefly summarize the story. "Three Hermits" is a simple yet profound tale about a bishop who is on a voyage to a remote island. During the journey, he hears from the sailors that there are three hermits living on the island who are considered holy. Curious, the bishop decides to visit these hermits to learn more about their way of life.
When the bishop arrives on the island, he finds the hermits, who are humble and uneducated, praying in a peculiar manner. They recite the Lord's Prayer but with some errors and awkward phrasing. The bishop is taken aback by their unconventional approach to prayer and decides to teach them the "correct" way to say the prayer.
He spends the entire day with them, attempting to teach them the proper wording of the prayer. The hermits, however, struggle to grasp the bishop's instructions and repeatedly make mistakes. Frustrated and exhausted, the bishop leaves the island in the evening, convinced that he has failed in his mission to correct the hermits' prayers.
That night, as the ship sails away, the bishop looks back and sees a radiant light on the island. He realizes that the three hermits are walking on the water, hand in hand, toward the ship. The hermits explain that they forgot the bishop's words as soon as he left, but that Christ Himself had come to them in a dream and blessed their way of praying. They tell the bishop that their simple, heartfelt prayer was acceptable to God, and they did not need to recite the words perfectly. The bishop is deeply moved and recognizes the hermits' genuine faith and the divine presence in their lives. He decides to let them continue their unorthodox way of praying.
Now, let's explore the theme of individual belief triumphing over religious dogma in "Three Hermits."
1. The Clash of Dogma and Simplicity:
The central conflict in the story arises from the clash between the dogmatic, ritualistic approach to prayer, as represented by the bishop, and the simple, heartfelt, and unorthodox method of the three hermits. The bishop embodies religious dogma, as he believes in the importance of saying prayers correctly and by the book. He feels compelled to correct the hermits, assuming that their unpolished prayer is a sign of ignorance and deviation from religious norms.
On the other hand, the hermits represent individual belief and a direct, personal connection with God. They do not follow the prescribed religious rituals but instead communicate with God in their own way. Their genuine faith and the divine response to their prayers demonstrate that faith transcends formalities and that the spirit of one's beliefs is more significant than adhering to rigid dogma.
2. The Bishop's Transformation:
The character of the bishop undergoes a significant transformation throughout the story. At the beginning, he is portrayed as a representative of religious authority and dogma. He believes in the supremacy of correct prayers and considers it his duty to correct the hermits' way of praying. However, as the story progresses, his encounter with the hermits challenges his rigid beliefs.
The pivotal moment occurs when the bishop witnesses the hermits walking on water, a miraculous event that defies the laws of nature. This experience forces the bishop to question his own understanding of faith and the limitations of religious dogma. He recognizes the authenticity of the hermits' connection with God and the acceptance of their unorthodox prayer by a divine presence. This realization leads to a profound shift in the bishop's perspective.
3. The Hermit's Faith and Simplicity:
The hermits, in contrast to the bishop, embody the idea that individual belief can be sincere and genuine without adhering to religious dogma. Their prayer is characterized by its simplicity, humility, and direct communication with God. They don't require elaborate rituals, doctrinal correctness, or the intervention of clergy to connect with the divine. Their unadorned approach to spirituality highlights the idea that true faith is a personal, heartfelt experience that can transcend religious formalities.
Their dream, in which Christ Himself appears and approves of their prayer, reinforces the notion that faith can be recognized and accepted by a higher power regardless of adherence to rigid dogma. The hermits' faith is a testament to the idea that religious institutions and formalities are not the sole arbiters of spirituality.
4. The Unpredictability of Divine Presence:
The story also suggests that the divine presence is not limited by human expectations or religious regulations. The bishop arrives on the island with the intention of instructing the hermits in the "correct" way to pray. However, when he departs, he witnesses a miracle—the hermits walking on water—accompanied by a radiant light. This miraculous event signifies the unpredictability of the divine presence and challenges the idea that religious dogma can control or define one's connection with the divine.
The hermits' experience with the divine is deeply personal and unique to them. It cannot be explained or validated by the bishop's doctrinal knowledge. This unpredictability reinforces the theme that individual belief and faith can transcend rigid religious dogma and lead to direct, personal encounters with the divine.
5. Lessons in Humility and Openness:
The story imparts lessons in humility and openness to the reader. The bishop, initially driven by pride and a sense of authority, is humbled by the hermits' simple faith and the miraculous event he witnesses. He recognizes that his role is not to dictate religious rules but to learn from the authentic faith of others.
The hermits, by their example, demonstrate that openness to the divine can be found in unexpected places and through unconventional means. Their humility and acceptance of the bishop's efforts to teach them highlight the idea that spirituality should be characterized by love, compassion, and an open heart rather than rigidity and arrogance.
6. Faith as a Personal Journey:
"Three Hermits" underscores the notion that faith is a deeply personal journey. It is not a one-size-fits-all experience that can be prescribed or controlled by religious dogma. Each individual's path to spirituality is unique and shaped by their personal beliefs, experiences, and connections with the divine.
The story illustrates that faith cannot be reduced to a set of rules or rituals. The hermits' unorthodox approach to prayer serves as a reminder that genuine faith is an authentic, internal experience that transcends external forms and rituals. This idea challenges the notion that religious dogma is the sole determinant of one's relationship with God.
7. The Universality of the Theme:
The theme of individual belief triumphing over religious dogma in "Three Hermits" is universal and transcends the specific religious context of the story. While the characters are Christian and the story features Christian prayers, the core message is applicable to people of various faiths and belief systems. It speaks to the idea that genuine, heartfelt faith can exist within any religious tradition and that it is not confined to rigid doctrinal requirements.
The story's themes are relevant to discussions of religious pluralism, interfaith dialogue, and the importance of recognizing the shared humanity and spirituality that unites people across different faiths. The universality of the theme makes "Three Hermits" a story that resonates with readers from diverse cultural and religious backgrounds.
8. A Call for Tolerance and Acceptance:
In "Three Hermits," Tolstoy subtly conveys a call for tolerance and acceptance of diverse beliefs and practices. The story serves as a reminder that the rigidity of religious dogma can lead to misunderstandings and conflicts. It encourages readers to be open-minded and respectful of the various ways in which individuals express their faith.
The bishop's initial insistence on doctrinal correctness and his subsequent realization of the hermits' authentic faith demonstrate the importance of humility and a willingness to learn from others. This message is especially relevant in a world marked by religious diversity and the need for mutual respect and understanding.
In conclusion, Leo Tolstoy's "Three Hermits" is a poignant and thought-provoking exploration of the theme of individual belief triumphing over religious dogma. Through the characters of the bishop and the hermits, Tolstoy demonstrates that faith is a deeply personal and heartfelt experience that transcends rigid religious dogma. The story emphasizes the importance of humility, openness, and the recognition that the divine can manifest itself in unpredictable and unconventional ways. While set within a Christian context, the story's themes have universal applicability and offer valuable lessons in tolerance, acceptance, and the power of individual belief. "Three Hermits" serves as a timeless reminder that spirituality and faith are deeply personal journeys that cannot be confined to external rituals or doctrinal regulations.
Subscribe on YouTube - NotesWorld
For PDF copy of Solved Assignment
Any University Assignment Solution
.webp)
