The Cournot and Bertrand models are two commonly used models in the study of oligopoly. These models attempt to explain how firms in a market with a small number of competitors interact with one another and make pricing decisions. In this article, we will differentiate between the Cournot and the Bertrand aamodel of oligopoly.
1. The Cournot Model:
The Cournot model is named after Antoine Augustin Cournot, a French mathematician, who developed this model in 1838. In the Cournot model, firms in an oligopoly compete on the basis of quantity produced rather than price. Each firm assumes that its competitors will keep their output levels constant and then determines the optimal quantity to produce based on this assumption. The equilibrium quantity and price are then determined by the interaction of these production decisions.
Assumptions of the Cournot Model:
* There are two or more firms in the market.
* Each firm assumes that its competitors will keep their output levels constant.
* Firms compete by choosing the quantity of output they will produce.
* Firms have identical production costs.
* The market is perfectly competitive.
Equilibrium in the Cournot Model:
The equilibrium in the Cournot model is determined by the interaction of the production decisions of the firms. Each firm assumes that its competitors will keep their output levels constant and then determines the optimal quantity to produce based on this assumption. The equilibrium quantity and price are then determined by the interaction of these production decisions.
For example, consider a market with two firms, A and B. Each firm has identical production costs and assumes that its competitor will keep its output level constant. Firm A produces Qa units of output, while firm B produces Qb units of output. The total quantity of output in the market is then Q = Qa + Qb. The market price is determined by the demand curve, which relates the market price to the total quantity of output. The equilibrium quantity and price are then determined by the interaction of the production decisions of the firms.
2. The Bertrand Model:
The Bertrand model is named after Joseph Bertrand, a French mathematician, who developed this model in 1883. In the Bertrand model, firms in an oligopoly compete on the basis of price rather than quantity produced. Each firm assumes that its competitors will keep their prices constant and then determines the optimal price to charge based on this assumption. The equilibrium price and quantity are then determined by the interaction of these price decisions.
Assumptions of the Bertrand Model:
* There are two or more firms in the market.
* Firms compete by choosing the price they will charge.
* Firms have identical production costs.
* The market is perfectly competitive.
Equilibrium in the Bertrand Model:
The equilibrium in the Bertrand model is determined by the interaction of the price decisions of the firms. Each firm assumes that its competitors will keep their prices constant and then determines the optimal price to charge based on this assumption. The equilibrium price and quantity are then determined by the interaction of these price decisions.
For example, consider a market with two firms, A and B. Each firm has identical production costs and assumes that its competitor will keep its price constant. Firm A charges price Pa, while firm B charges price Pb. The market price is then determined by the lowest price charged, as customers will choose to buy from the firm charging the lowest price. The equilibrium price and quantity are then determined by the interaction of the price decisions of the firms.
Comparison of Cournot and Bertrand Model:
1. Quantity versus Price Competition:
The main difference between the Cournot and Bertrand model is the type of competition that takes place. In the Cournot model, firms compete on the basis of quantity produced, while in the Bertrand model, firms compete on the basis of price charged.
2. Assumptions about Competitor Behavior:
Another key difference between the Cournot and Bertrand models is the assumption about how firms view their competitors. In the Cournot model, each firm assumes that its competitors will keep their output levels constant, while in the Bertrand model, each firm assumes that its competitors will keep their prices constant. These assumptions reflect different views of how firms interact in the market.
3. Equilibrium Outcomes:
The equilibrium outcomes in the Cournot and Bertrand models can be quite different. In the Cournot model, the equilibrium quantity of output produced by each firm is typically less than the monopoly quantity and greater than the competitive quantity. In the Bertrand model, the equilibrium price is typically equal to the marginal cost of production and the quantity produced by each firm is equal to the competitive quantity.
4. Multiple Equilibria:
The Bertrand model can have multiple equilibria, while the Cournot model typically has only one equilibrium. This is because in the Bertrand model, firms can undercut each other by charging lower prices, leading to a situation where multiple price points can be stable. In the Cournot model, however, there is only one quantity that maximizes profit for each firm, so there is only one stable equilibrium.
5. Strategic Interaction:
Finally, the strategic interaction between firms is different in the two models. In the Cournot model, firms must take into account the likely response of their competitors when choosing how much to produce. In the Bertrand model, firms must take into account the likely response of their competitors when choosing what price to charge.
Conclusion:
In conclusion, the Cournot and Bertrand models are two different approaches to analyzing oligopoly competition. The Cournot model focuses on competition based on quantity produced, while the Bertrand model focuses on competition based on price charged. Both models make simplifying assumptions about the behavior of firms and the nature of the market, but they provide useful frameworks for understanding how firms in an oligopoly interact with each other.
Subscribe on YouTube - NotesWorld
For PDF copy of Solved Assignment
Any University Assignment Solution
.webp)
